If you’ve ever stuck to a diet or training plan for a few weeks, only to watch your motivation fade and your old habits creep back in, you’re not alone.
It’s one of the most common patterns I’ve seen in over three decades in the fitness world: people don’t fail because they lack information. They fail because they don’t understand optimal motivation.
3 Keys To Self-Motivation, According To Psychology
Most people believe motivation comes from the outside: rewards, punishments, deadlines, and “carrots and sticks.” Those things can work for a little while. You can white-knuckle your way to a short-term goal with enough outside pressure. But as soon as the prize or external push disappears, motivation is gone just as fast.
Psychologist Edward Deci, along with his colleague Richard Ryan, spent decades studying this problem. Out of their work came Self-Determination Theory (SDT), the leading scientific model of human motivation.
SDT says that long-term, high-quality motivation comes from the inside and depends on satisfying three basic psychological needs, which you can remember with a simple acronym – ARC:
Autonomy – feeling that you have choice and control over your actions.
Relatedness – feeling connected to, supported by, and engaged with other people.
Competence – feeling effective, capable, and steadily improving.
When these three needs are supported, intrinsic motivation grows – that’s the kind of motivation where the activity itself becomes rewarding and you want to do it because you enjoy the process. You eat well because it feels good, not just because you’re chasing a reward or ego-based outcome.
When these needs are undermined – by rigid rules, controlling coaches, or environments built entirely on external rewards – motivation becomes fragile. You might comply for a while, but you don’t stay engaged over the long term.
Until now, most of the writing and research on intrinsic motivation has focused on interpersonal situations with a clear “one-up / one-down” relationship:
- Teachers and students
- Managers and employees
- Coaches and athletes
- Parents and children
- Doctors and patients
Those are important contexts, but there has been much less written about how an individual can apply this knowledge to their own health and fitness goals.
Deci did include some weight loss and health examples in his research and in his book, Why We Do What We Do, but much of his applied work focused on how professionals (like doctors) can communicate in more autonomy-supportive ways.
Other popular books on motivation such as Daniel Pink’s Drive have touched briefly on fitness in passing, but with most examples coming from business and work.
This article is designed to help fill that gap by focusing on fitness. What you’re about to read is a practical, fitness-specific guide: eight ways you can tap into intrinsic motivation to make sticking to your training and nutrition almost effortless.
These ideas are based on Self-Determination Theory and the broader research on intrinsic motivation, adapted specifically for health, fat loss, and long-term fitness.
Put these in place and you won’t have to keep trying to “pump yourself up” every Monday. Your “A.R.C.” of motivation will start to pull you forward from the inside.
8 Ways To Tap Into Intrinsic Motivation For Fitness
1. Choose your own nutrition plan.
Do not follow cookie cutter diet plans. Always customize your nutrition to your own goals, lifestyle, schedule, and personal preferences. Never let any coach, expert or guru shoehorn you into their one eating philosophy – it may not be the right one for you.
Do not feel pressured to follow any diet brand or philosophy 100% by the book – take parts that fit you and discard the rest.
If you like eating carbs, do not follow a low carb diet – you won’t sustain it. If you need the help, hire a coach to guide you and give you important targets like calories, macros, and food selections, but make sure you have the freedom to chose how you will hit those targets.
For example, a calorie deficit is non-negotiable for fat loss, but you have many options for how you do it. You should pick the diet that gets you in the calorie deficit in the easiest, most painless and sustainable way possible.
It’s all about autonomy – feeling like you have the power to choose your own plan is a major key to staying self-motivated.
2. Choose your own training plan.
Choose the training plan that suits your goals, lifestyle, schedule, and personal preferences the best. Never let any coach, expert or guru force you into their one training philosophy – it may not be right for you. Do not feel pressured to strictly follow any workout plan or exercise philosophy 100% by the book.
Hire a coach to guide you, give you advice and help you set important targets like sets, reps, frequency, intensity, volume and so on, but make sure you have the final say in everything, and make sure you feel as if you have control over most of the program design.
Again, it’s all about choice. When you feel like you had a hand in designing your training plan rather than having it forced on you, you’ll be more motivated and consistent for the long term.
In addition, make sure the training plan you choose is sustainable, both in terms of how much work your body can handle, and what you can realistically fit into your schedule if you are busy.
3. Set your own goals.
Goals that are self-chosen almost always produce more sustainable motivation.
Getting healthy and fit so you can be there for your family or set an example for others is a good use of tapping into the power of purpose as long as the goal is your own choice. But starting a diet or training program because someone else is pressuring you to do it is not.
Starting a specific type of trendy diet or training program because someone else thinks you should is also the wrong reason.
4. Set the right kind of goals for the right reasons.
People who pursue goals for extrinsic reasons, such as winning a fitness contest or slimming down for a wedding, class reunion, or vacation very often reach those goals. Goal setting and external motivation does work and there is nothing wrong with pursuing prizes, praise, or approval as a short-term motivator.
The problem is, people who depend only on external motivators usually gain the weight back or get out of shape again as soon as the event has ended or rewards are gone.
People who pursue goals such as getting fit to feel good, to stay healthy for their family, to be a role model for others, to honor their creator, or any other intrinsic reason that’s importanat to them are much more likely to maintain their results in the long run. The key is that these goals are self-chosen and align with your values.
5. Find a form of exercise you enjoy and do anything you can to make it more fun and engaging.
If you hate treadmills, then ditch the treadmill. If you dislike gyms, train at home. If you don’t like barbells, do resistance training with body weight, bands, or suspension straps. Whatever your preferences, it’s absolutely possible to find a form of exercise that’s not only enjoyable, but intoxicating – that gives you those feelings of having a peak experience (putting you in a state of flow).
It can go beyond resistance training and cardio training. It can include sports, martial arts, or even dancing. It could be group training or doing it solo. It could be recreation, or walking on the beach or in the park or woods. Using a progress journal and forever aiming to reach little daily workout goals and set new personal records can turn workouts that were a drudge into feeling like a game.
Just as work can be turned into play, exercise can be turned into play as well an when you do that, you’ll be motivated from within to stick to it.
6. Pursue mastery.
When you feel like you’re getting better at something or at least learning – to become more competent – it gives you a great source of renewable motivation.
The martial arts are a prime example of a sport and discipline that people strive to master for life, and the concept of mastery is easy to understand in that context. But general fitness pursuits – resistance and cardio training – can also be approached as a craft that you work on mastering.
So pick some kind of training that you can get better at over time – not just increasing strength, endurance or other measures of fitness, but actually mastering the prescription and execution of training as if it were an art form. For some people, the type of training is CrossFit, powerlifting, calisthenics, or Spartan races.
For me it’s bodybuilding, and I look at bodybuilding not only as a science but also as an art or craft. You could do it for a lifetime and never master it, but by seeking mastery, I never need outside motivation, the pursuit of mastering the craft is the reward. If there is outside motivation like a competition with a trophy, title, or award, it’s simply an extra boost and bonus.
7. Set goals of the right difficulty level.
Choose goals that are just a notch above your current ability. They should be challenging enough to make you stretch, but not so difficult or far away that they demotivate you.
This is the “goldilocks zone” for goals – not too hard, not too easy. As you reach each higher level, continue to increase the difficulty level, always set new goals, and you will stay motivated.
8. Get connected to supportive people and stay connected.
According to Self-Determination Theory, one of our innate human needs is relatedness or connection to others. This theory says when our innate needs are met, we are not only more motivated but also happier. When these needs are thwarted, our motivation and happiness plummet.
We are social creatures. Goals that have you interacting with others, giving and receiving help from like minded people and nurturing relationships are going to fill your innate need for connection and improve your success rate.
Always have a social support system to plug into, whether online or in real life and ideally, both. Also consider whether you are the type of person who enjoys participating in exercise with a group. Not everyone does, but for some people, the community aspect of group fitness can be a game changer.
Conclusion: Generate Fitness Motivation From the Inside Out
Intrinsic motivation is not about willpower tricks or morning pep talks. It’s about designing your fitness life so that your basic psychological needs are met:
- You choose your path (Autonomy).
- You feel supported and connected (Relatedness).
- You get better over time (Competence).
The research from Edward Deci and others is clear: when these needs are satisfied, people don’t just comply for a little while – they engage. They stick with their goals through obstacles, setbacks, and the ups and downs of real life.
Use the ARC of motivation concept and the eight ideas above to build something deeper: a lifestyle where training and healthy eating are part of your identity, aligned with your values, and , not just something you feel like you should do because outside pressure.
When you tap the motivation inside you, fitness stops being a temporary project and starts becoming something you pursue for its own sake. The activity itself becomes the reward, and that will keep you going for life.
The Next Burn The Fat Body Transformation challenge Starts On January 1st here On the Burn the Fat Inner Circle website. CLICK HERE to see the challenge calendar
About Tom Venuto
Tom Venuto is a natural bodybuilding and fat loss coach with 35 years of experience. He holds a degree in exercise science and has trained hundreds of clients in person. He is also a recipe creator specializing in fat-burning, muscle-building cooking.
A former competitive bodybuilder, Tom is now a full-time evidence-based fitness writer, blogger, and author. His classic book Burn the Fat, Feed the Muscle is an international bestseller, first as an ebook and later as a hardcover and audiobook. His newest book. Extreme Fat Loss, which analyzes controversial diet and training programs, became an instant bestseller in 2025.
Tom’s work has been featured in Men’s Fitness, Oprah Magazine and dozens of other major publications. He is best known for his no-BS, evidence based approach to natural fat loss and muscle-building.
Tom is also the founder of Burn the Fat Inner Circle, a fitness support community with more than 53,000 members worldwide since 2006.
Leave A Comment